Cool like a disease
Monday, February 27th, 2006I read an essay today on Salmagundi, The Price of Irony, which is more or less a polemic against the tyrannous reign of irony in our day and age (particularly in theater and literature) and now I’m angry with myself because I thought about writing this essay last year, though mine probably wouldn’t have been as good. I’m sure there are a dozen more floating around out there anyways. Here’s a few sentences from the second paragraph:
"Irony is the postmodern form of conspicuous self-consciousness and suits
our era’s puerility – its fey aestheticism and political
cynicism — to a tee. It is complacency’s rationalization,
disengagement’s excuse, the alienated spectator’s self-justification.
The ironic bystander (the phrase is redundant) is the citizen’s
jeering nemesis and the poet’s wily shadow trying to make
sure that truth and beauty and goodness, those stalwarts of the world before it was disenchanted, do not re-infect the post-modern’s cool voice with hot earnestness. Or make us think too hard or feel
too keenly."
It goes on to discuss (and trash) McDonaugh’s play Pillowman as an example of of what he’s talking about (a comedy invovling child molestation and torture — actually, I’ve been wanting to read it).
I like that kind of stuff as much as the next guy, probably more, but really I’m sick to death of it. I’m starving for some more voices that least flirt with sincerity, stories with something at their core. (Irony probably too big a term to throw around like the author of the above essay does, but I’m talking about the flippant, aloof, and often vicious sort of stuff that creates distance between the reader and the world — basically, the chickenshit posturing of people that are clever but don’t really have anything to say)
Of course, irony is sometimes hard to resist, as pockets of mainstream culture are completely without a sense of it. We don’t even have to get into politics and news media — just witness the rise of reality television or check the lyrics to the top forty songs. I recently had the misfortune of catching a video of a song called Rock-N-Roll Queen (by Subways):
You are the sun,
You are the only one,
My heart is blue,
My heart is blue for you
Be my, be my, be my little rock & roll queen
be my, be my, be my little rock & roll queen
You are the sun,
You are the only one,
You are so cool,
You are so rock & roll
To be fair, there’s a lot better stuff out there, even on MTV, but there’s a lot more just like that, daily proof that God has abandoned us (otherwise he’d be casting some f’ing lightning on those dudes, turning their guitars into cobras, working some miracles to cleanse the world). I saw this video on MTV while shooting pool, but then the VJ came on, and he was wearing a sweatshirt with a couple of eighteen-wheelers and American flags raising in the background, like something you’d find in a truckstop in Kansas. So as MTV tries to cash in on irony, they do it in such a unsubtle way that its hard to see it as anything but mean-spirited (does this whole ironic trucker pose amount to anything more than a bunch of spoiled upper-middle class kids making fun of the working class?). Anyways, I do hold out hope that, if nothing else, more writers will tire of the type of irony I’ve been complaining about: intellectually vapid, emotionally cold, morally bankrupt.